It is difficult to talk about football at the moment without mentioning the Manchester City verdict, with the Premier League confirming that the club is guilty of 114 of the 115 charges that were brought against it. On the one hand, the Cityzens are lucky that it’s been an international break, so they haven’t felt the full impact of the anger of match-going supporters in the ground. On the other, it has meant that we’ve all had nothing else to talk about, so City are being attacked on virtually every podcast and TV show that deals with the English top-flight. As I sat down thinking about what to write this week, I couldn’t really look anywhere else but to the Etihad, given the fact that there has been no football that I care about taking place for the past fortnight, so what else was I going to end up putting pen to paper (or finger to keyboard) about other than their confirmed cheating? It doesn’t look like we’ll have much else to talk about for a while, either.
Man City when asked to provide their “irrefutable evidence.”
— ET Heisenberg (@utdheisenberg.bsky.social) 30 September 2026 at 00:10
It should surprise precisely nobody that Manchester City chose to appeal the verdict, meaning that the case will drag on for even longer. I have heard some suggestion that they could even end up taking it as far as the High Court, so even a rejection of their appeal by the independent body that the Premier League will set up won’t necessarily draw the matter to a close. Then there’s the influence that is almost certainly being placed on those concerned from the outside, with the Prime Minister himself, Evertonian Andy Burnham, weighing in and suggesting that a guilty verdict wouldn’t be great politically. Although City have very much lost in the court of public opinion, the only thing that they’ll care about is whether they end up losing in the actual court, which I’m not convinced is likely to happen, given the geo-political situation and the need for the United Arab Emirates to continue to invest money into the United Kingdom.
Validation for Those of Us That Have Been Crying Foul for Years
Let’s be honest about this. The vast majority of us have known for years that Manchester City have been playing a different game to the rest of the Premier League. The idea that they somehow went from being a team that barely anyone in Manchester even cared about to being bigger on a global scale than Liverpool, Manchester United and Real Madrid was always laughable. I have repeatedly banged the drum that none of their achievements are worth a jot, on account of the fact that it was clear that they weren’t going about their success the right way. As much as I despise United and hope that they never win as much as a raffle, there is no argument about the club’s intelligence behind the scenes during the 1990s that led them to become a commercial powerhouse. Similarly, even those that don’t like Fenway Sports Group as owners would struggle to make a coherent argument that they haven’t been excellent in making the Reds so financially viable.
UAE officials have warned the UK that a severe punishment for Man City could hurt future Emirati investment in Britain, Bloomberg reports.
This is the perfect argument for keeping foreign money out of football.
— Mark Chadbourn (@chadbourn.bsky.social) 2 October 2026 at 11:04
The Premier League have now declared Manchester City to have been cheating over the period of time that was considered by the panel, which is a vindication for those of us that have long been saying as much. Even if you decided to take the most generous view possible and decide that the cheating stopped in 2018, everything that the club has won in the years since has come from the fruit of the poisoned tree. Whilst Pep Guardiola is unquestionably a brilliant manager of top-class players, there is zero chance that he turns up at the Etihad without the club having spent the money that it had spent, to say nothing of giving him a blank cheque with which to sign whatever players he felt he needed to compete. Every single trophy that sits in the club’s cabinet would not be there without the jiggery-pokery that resulted in a guilty charge in 114 of the 115 cases that the Premier League brought against the club, so their success is nothing but a sham.
What Comes Next is All That Matters
Whilst the Premier League’s declaration that Man City have cheated on an industrial scale for a period of years validates what myself and others have been saying virtually ever since the Abu Dhabi regime arrived in England as owners, it does little to change what has been recorded in the record books. The truth of the matter is that the titles, cup wins and all other success has to be stripped from the football club, or else the guilty verdict is basically an irrelevance. Similarly, if the club isn’t kicked out of the top-flight and all the way down to non-league football, they will just get back to winning ways in virtually no time at all, which also renders the verdict as all but meaningless. I am more than aware that there are plenty of people who do not believe that the titles and other trophies shouldn’t be awarded to whoever finished as runners-up, but I’m not one of them. From a Liverpool point of view, we won those titles and so we should be awarded them.
I can’t lie, the reaction of Man City’s ownership in the last week has radicalised me into wanting the punishment to be as harsh as possible.
This time a week ago, I thought some of the punishments being proposed sounded excessive. But the lack of contrition makes me think there should be no mercy
— Treblig 🇺🇦 (@camtreblig.bsky.social) 4 October 2026 at 22:18
You can’t tell me that Jürgen Klopp’s team, which racked up 97 points and a Champions League, doesn’t deserve to be thought of as a double-winning team. Yes, we don’t get the moment of celebration as we would’ve got if we’d won it in real time, but the record books need to show that that Liverpool side was one of the best ever to play the game. Taking the trophies away from City isn’t enough on its own; the parties that were wronged by their cheating also deserve recognition for their achievements. I say that fully in the knowledge that Manchester United will benefit just as much as the Reds if that were to happen. Hate them as much as I do, I’m still able to accept that they achieved their success the right way. It is important that the record books reflect as much. Although we all hope that City’s appeal will fail, the truth of the matter is that they will always be remembered as the Lance Armstrong of football.
